Originally I was excited to attend the music production lecture given by Darrin Vincent, long time Ricky Skaggs bandmate and member of IBMA winning group Dailey and Vincent. I want to be clear that Darrin is extremely talented as producer, musician, and an artist. Dailey and Vincent are very deserving of their recent awards.
Darrin made alot of good points against basement and bedroom studio recording, but I quickly became disapointed when he began talking recording formats. He talked about how important they are and proceeded to list them… pro tools, nuendo, radar, etc… everything was mentioned but analog tape. This is very surprising in the bluegrass genre and I immediately spoke up… “what about analog?” He dismissed the notion like it was a long gone thing of the past and quickly moved on. Very disapointing!
This is very puzzling to me, being that Darrin’s longtime former band leader Ricky Skaggs records to analog tape. Ricky, unpleased with the sound of digital recording, quit using certain Nashville studios when they switched to digital in the 90’s. Ricky’s own studio now records to a 16 track analog machine and trasnfers into iZ Radar.
Darrin then spoke of producing the Cherryholmes band. He mentioned that at times Jere Cherryholmes was not satisfied with the sound, asking why it didn’t sound like Ricky Skaggs’ album he brought in as a reference. Darrin explained that without the expensive guitars and such, it simply could not sound the same… which I suspect is only partially true.
Obviously it’s going to be hard to sound anywhere near as good as Cody Kilby, but… considering that Ricky’s album would have been tracked to tape, this may have been much more of a factor that an inferior guitar. Although I have been unsuccessful at finding out what recorder was actually used and I regret not asking Darrin at the time, I would guess that Jere Cherryholmes was missing that extra magic tape can add to your tracks… especially acoustic bluegrass tracks. He was missing the warm tone and smooth dynamics that properly driven tape can give… not to mention the overall blend of instruments.
Contrary to popular belief, tape is still available and some studios are still using it frequently and understand the benefits. Combined with the new tools digital has given us creates one of the most powerful set of tools engineers have ever had. Track in analog and mix in Pro Tools… The best of both worlds! The difference is worth it. Shocking in the bluegrass world to find a bass player who dismisses analog in front of a room of bluegrass industry professionals.